Evidence and Documents

This website brings together source documents, maps, correspondence, government records and community research relating to the proposed Gonneville development and its associated infrastructure.

Wherever possible, we link directly to the original source so you can read the evidence and make up your own mind.

ASK THE QUESTION. ASK FOR THE EVIDENCE. CHECK THE ANSWER.

23 Years in the Proposal. “Well Beyond 23” in the Investor Pitch. What Is the EPA Assessing?

Chalice describes Gonneville as a 23-year open-pit mine. But its public materials also discuss mining that could continue beyond that period.

That raises an important question for the EPA’s assessment: does 23 years define the project being assessed, or is it the current modelled mine plan within a project that could continue much longer?

What the current proposal says

In its proposed Section 43A amendment, Chalice has asked the EPA to remove underground mine access from the project under assessment. Chalice’s website also says the expected mine life has changed from 25 years to 23 years.

As of 7 November 2026, the EPA had not yet decided whether to accept the amendment. The public comment period has closed, and the EPA says the broader proposal will later be open for an eight-week public review.

What Chalice tells investors

In its September 2026 Corporate Presentation, Chalice said that only about half of the Resource is included in the open-pit phase and that the mine is “expected to transition to underground” and go “well beyond 23yrs.”

Its November 2026 Corporate Presentation repeated that statement.

The 2026 Annual Report says the Pre-Feasibility Study does not include a “likely transition” to large-scale underground mining. In other words, Chalice describes underground mining as likely in its public materials while seeking to remove underground mine access from the proposal now before the EPA.

That does not prove the company has acted unlawfully. It does make the scope of the environmental assessment an important question: how will the EPA account for a future phase that Chalice itself describes as likely or expected?

The 55-year scenario needs careful explanation

The Annual Report also identifies a separate scenario: if economic conditions did not incentivise the Stage 2 processing expansion, a similar mine plan could be followed over about 55 years instead of 23.

That is a conditional modelled alternative, not Chalice’s stated expected mine life. The same passage says Chalice considers both Stage 1 and Stage 2 to be incentivised under conditions well below its base-case assumptions.

The 55-year scenario still matters. It raises questions about whether the 23 years is a firm limit on operations, or simply the duration of the current production model. A lower-throughput operation could mean a longer period of mining-related impacts, even if the footprint were similar.

What does the law require?

Section 43A of Western Australia’s Environmental Protection Act 1986 allows the EPA to consider changes to a proposal while it is being assessed. It is the EPA’s decision whether to accept a proposed change.

The Act also requires the EPA to consider cumulative effects. Its 2026 Cumulative Impact Assessment Guideline says future activities by a proponent may be relevant where they are already approved, in an approvals process, or otherwise reasonably likely to proceed. The guideline does not automatically mean every possible future mine stage must be fully assessed now. But Chalice’s statements that underground mining is likely or expected give the EPA a clear reason to explain how it has treated that possibility.

There is a separate issue for investor disclosures. ASIC says statements about future matters must have reasonable grounds when made. That rule does not decide what belongs in an EPA assessment, but it makes the basis for confident public forecasts a legitimate question.

Questions the EPA should answer

Before decisions are made, the EPA should clarify:

  • Is 23 years a proposed limit on the project’s operating life, or a modelled schedule?

  • Could the approximately 55-year lower-throughput scenario occur within the approvals being sought?

  • How have the longer-term underground scenario and its potential environmental effects been treated in the assessment?

  • If future mining would require a new approval, what activities, impacts and cumulative effects are being assessed now, and what would be left to a later process?

The issue is not whether future underground mining has already been approved. It has not. The issue is whether the EPA and the community are being given a clear picture of the development Chalice says it expects to pursue, and the potential length of time the region could live with its effects.

The community deserves a clear answer: what project is the EPA assessing, and what is the 23-year figure actually meant to limit?

Sources

Chalice presentations:

Chalice financial reports:

Chalice ASX announcements:

Chalice investor presentations and reports:

EPA’s Gonneville amendment

EPA Consultation Hub:

EPA cumulative impact guidance:

ASIC forward-looking statements guidance:

PROPOSED GONNEVILLE INFRASTRUCTURE CORRIDORS — 2026

Source: Chalice Mining, Infrastructure Update, May 2026.

This regional overview shows the proposed infrastructure connections between Alkimos, Muchea and Gonneville. It does not identify the precise alignment across individual properties or the full extent of potentially affected vegetation, waterways and rural land.63km LONG. 100 METRE WIDE.

CHALICE’S INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT ENVELOPE

Source: Gonneville Project Proposal Content Document, Figure 3 — March 2024

63KM LONG. 100 METRE WIDE.

THE INFRASTRUCTURE CORRIDOR

The Gonneville Project extends far beyond the proposed mine site.

Chalice is investigating a major off-site infrastructure corridor extending approximately 63 kilometres through parts of Toodyay, Chittering and Wanneroo.

The current assessment corridor is approximately 100 metres wide. Chalice says this is not the final clearing footprint and that the eventual area required for infrastructure would be narrower as designs and routes are refined.

But right now, this is the corridor being investigated — and for the people whose properties, vegetation and wildlife habitat fall within it, its final footprint matters enormously.

THIS IS NOT AN EMPTY LANDSCAPE

The proposed corridor crosses established rural and rural-residential areas containing homes, farms, native vegetation, waterways and wildlife habitat.

Some families have lived on these properties for many years. Others bought and moved into their homes much more recently.

For affected landholders, the issue is therefore much more than a line drawn across a project map.

It is what construction, clearing, excavation, permanent infrastructure, access and ongoing maintenance could mean for the future use, productivity, amenity and character of their properties.

In parts of Maryville Heights, the proposed corridor also intersects land containing Tree Preservation Areas established through the subdivision process.

Landholders bought properties containing vegetation they were required to protect.

Now major mine-related infrastructure is being investigated through the same landscape.

That raises a simple but important question:

What happens when privately protected land becomes part of a proposed infrastructure corridor?

WHAT WOULD THE CORRIDOR ACTUALLY CONTAIN?

The proposed infrastructure corridor is intended to accommodate more than a single piece of infrastructure.

Current project information identifies three key components:

a high-voltage electricity transmission line

a water pipeline

an access/maintenance road.

Together, these would require associated clearing, construction access and infrastructure for ongoing operation and maintenance.

POWER INFRASTRUCTURE

Chalice currently proposes an approximately 27-kilometre, 132 kV dual-circuit electricity transmission connection between Gonneville and Muchea.

Importantly, the design has already changed.

Chalice now says the powerline would be placed underground through the rural-residential area around Maryville Heights and adjoining agricultural land.

Undergrounding removes overhead transmission structures from that part of the landscape, but it does not remove the need to understand the construction footprint.

For affected landholders, important questions remain about excavation, vegetation clearing, construction access, the width of the final disturbance area and the access required to inspect, repair and maintain the infrastructure over its operational life.

WATER INFRASTRUCTURE

The proposed water infrastructure extends much further.

Chalice is investigating a pipeline corridor of approximately 63 kilometres between Gonneville and the coast, intended to provide a future water supply for the project.

Like the power connection, the final construction footprint has not yet been fixed.

That distinction matters.

The 100 metre corridor currently being investigated is not the same thing as 100 metres of clearing, but until the final alignment and disturbance footprint are determined, landholders within that corridor do not yet know precisely what part of their properties may ultimately be required.

TREE PRESERVATION AREAS

Parts of the proposed infrastructure corridor pass through properties within the Maryville Heights subdivision containing designated Tree Preservation Areas.

These areas are not simply patches of vegetation that happened to remain after subdivision.

Their protection formed part of the environmental planning for Maryville Heights, and affected properties were created with restrictions and responsibilities relating to the retention and protection of native vegetation.

For some families, that protected bushland and the wildlife habitat it provides was part of the reason they chose to buy and live there.

The proposed Gonneville infrastructure corridor now intersects this same landscape.

That creates an unusual situation.

Landholders who have been required to protect native vegetation on their properties are now faced with the possibility that some of that same landscape could be disturbed for major mine-related infrastructure.

The final alignment and disturbance footprint have not yet been determined.

Until they are, an important question remains:

How will the existing protections placed on these properties be reconciled with the infrastructure now proposed through them?

BLACK COCKATOOS & BREEDING HABITAT

The proposed corridor also passes through and alongside habitat used by threatened black cockatoos.

Mature native trees in this landscape can provide feeding and roosting habitat and, where suitable hollows occur, potential or confirmed breeding habitat.

Carnaby’s Black-Cockatoos and Forest Red-tailed Black-Cockatoos are recorded in the wider area, and breeding hollows have been identified within the Tree Preservation Area affected by the proposed corridor.

These trees cannot be considered simply as hectares of vegetation.

A mature hollow bearing tree can represent habitat that has taken well over a century to develop.

That makes the final alignment, construction footprint and protection of mature habitat trees particularly important as the corridor is assessed.

WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR LANDHOLDERS?

If a property is affected by permanent infrastructure, what happens to loss of amenity, changes to outlook and character, ongoing access requirements or any effect on property value?

Along parts of the proposed corridor, this is not simply private land. It is working farmland, including properties that have been held and farmed by families for generations.

For these landholders, the potential impact extends beyond the physical area occupied by infrastructure. Loss of productive land, changes to access and farm operations, and the effect on the future income and use of the property all matter.

For a farming family, land is not just where they live. It can be their livelihood, their history and what they intended to pass on to the next generation.

And there is a longer-term question.

Gonneville's proposed electricity connection is being planned while major expansion of the wider electricity network in the Chittering region is also being considered. These are separate projects, but communities deserve clarity about how they relate and what infrastructure may ultimately remain in this landscape.

The corridor is not final.

Neither are the questions.

SOURCES & OFFICIAL RECORDS

EPA — GONNEVILLE PROJECT

Official Environmental Protection Authority record for the Gonneville Project.

Includes the original referral documents, proposal maps, EPA assessment decision and the approved Environmental Scoping Document.

VIEW EPA PROJECT RECORD

https://www.epa.wa.gov.au/proposals/gonneville-nickel-copper-platinum-group-element-pge-project

COMMONWEALTH — EPBC ACT RECORD

Official Commonwealth environmental assessment record for the Gonneville Project.

The project is EPBC 2024/09839 and was determined to be a Controlled Action requiring assessment and approval under the EPBC Act.

VIEW EPBC PROJECT RECORD

https://epbcpublicportal.environment.gov.au/all-referrals/project-referral-summary/?id=90817fb8-e4eb-ee11-a1fd-002248103353

GONNEVILLE — INFRASTRUCTURE CORRIDOR

Chalice's project page for the proposed off-site infrastructure corridor.

Includes the preferred corridor map, project status, landholder information and details of investigations undertaken to date.

VIEW INFRASTRUCTURE CORRIDOR

https://www.gonnevilleproject.com.au/infrastructure-update/

GONNEVILLE — ENVIRONMENTAL APPROVALS

Chalice's project page outlining the State and Commonwealth environmental assessment and approvals processes for Gonneville.

Includes information about the mine development area, environmental studies, infrastructure corridors and the Environmental Review Document process.

VIEW ENVIRONMENTAL APPROVALS

https://www.gonnevilleproject.com.au/environmental-approvals/